Cakes, Cupcakes (31)

First Street Loaf Cake, Lemon, Sliced, 16 Ounce, $5.00

Loaf Cake, Lemon, Sliced

First Street Loaf Cake, Marble, Sliced, 16 Ounce, $5.00

Loaf Cake, Marble, Sliced

First Street Brownie, Squares, Premium, 14 Ounce, $6.00

Brownie, Squares, Premium

First Street Loaf Cake, Vanilla, Sliced, 16 Ounce, $5.00

Loaf Cake, Vanilla, Sliced

Our Specialty Cake, Variety, 46 Ounce, $15.59

Cake, Variety

First Street Loaf Cake, Cinnamon Swirl, Sliced, 16 Ounce, $5.00

Loaf Cake, Cinnamon Swirl, Sliced

First Street Loaf Cake, Blueberry, Sliced, 16 Ounce, $5.00

Since 1871.

First Street Bundt Cake, Chocolate Lovers' Delight, 36 Ounce, $11.19

Bundt Cake, Chocolate Lovers' Delight

Sevan Cupcakes, 28 Ounce, $9.99

Two-Bite Cupcakes, Vanilla, 10 Ounce, $4.99

Cupcakes, Vanilla

First Street Brownie Bites, Premium, Chewy & Decadent, 32 Ounce, $9.99

Brownie Bites, Premium, Chewy & Decadent

Kimberley's Everyday Large Assorted Cupcakes, 22 Ounce, $9.99

First Street Bundt Cake, Buttermilk Cinnamon Streusel, 36 Ounce, $11.19

Bundt Cake, Buttermilk Cinnamon Streusel

Two-Bite Cupcakes, Chocolate, 10 Ounce, $4.99

Now nut free!

First Street Cake, Pound, 16 Ounce, $5.99

Cake, Pound

First Street Bundt Cake, Louisiana Crunch, 36 Ounce, $11.19

Moist citrus flavored cake with a coconut crumb topping.

First Street Bundt Cake, Lemon, 36 Ounce, $11.19

Bundt Cake, Lemon

Decadence Chocolate Espresso Swirl Cake 16 oz, 16 Ounce, $6.00

Chalet Desserts White Chocolate Cake Pops, 8 Each, $9.99

First Street Brownie Bites, Plain, Sugar & Powdered Sugar, 36 Ounce, $16.99

Brownie Bites, Plain, Sugar & Powdered Sugar

Tiramisu Swirl Bundt Cake, 16 Ounce, $6.00

Decadence Raspberry White Chocolate Swirl Cake 16 oz, 16 Ounce, $6.00

Salted Caramel Decadent Bundt Cake, 16 Ounce, $6.00

First Street Brownies, with Walnuts, Chocolate Fudge, 32 Ounce, $12.99

Brownies, with Walnuts, Chocolate Fudge

Sugarbowl Brownie Bites IW, 16 Ounce, $8.99

Decadence Triple Citrus Swirl Cake 16 oz, 16 Ounce, $6.00

First Street Duo Bites, Premium, 16 Ounce, $8.49

Duo Bites, Premium

Two-Bite Cupcakes, Vanilla, 10 Ounce, $4.99

Cupcakes, Vanilla

Two-Bite Brownies, Original, 14 Ounce, $8.99

Brownies, Original

First Street Bundt Cake, Red Velvet, 36 Ounce, $11.19

Bundt Cake, Red Velvet